I've been working with Victory Tax Law now for over 2 years and I couldn't be happier. It’s rare to find a firm that combines professionalism with genuine care, but they do. I can always count on them to do a stellar job because they've always had my best interests in mind.
Tax Attorney in Butte County
Federal IRS and California state tax representation for taxpayers across Butte County — from the county seat in Oroville through Chico, Paradise, Gridley, and Biggs, the agricultural floor of the Sacramento Valley, the foothill canyon communities along the Feather River, and the unincorporated towns of Magalia, Concow, Berry Creek, Forest Ranch, Cohasset, Durham, Palermo, Bangor, and Yankee Hill. Our California Bar-admitted attorneys handle IRS audits, FTB collection cases, lingering 2018 Camp Fire casualty-loss and involuntary-conversion files, CSU Chico fellowship and stipend exposure under IRC §117, Sacramento Valley rice, almond, walnut, kiwi, and prune Schedule F audits, Enloe Medical Center physician 1099 and RSU work, U.S. Tax Court petitions designated to Sacramento, CDTFA determinations, and EDD payroll audits. Headquartered in Los Angeles at 1100 S. Robertson Boulevard, with direct phone and secure-portal coverage for all of Butte County.
By Parham Khorsandi, Esq. — California Bar #266658. Admitted to practice before the United States Tax Court. Last Reviewed: .
Request a Free Consultation
100% Free · Confidential · No Obligation
Cal Bar Admitted
Verifiable license #266658
U.S. Tax Court
Federal trial admission
BBB Accredited
A+ rating
5.0 / 72 Reviews
Google Business Profile
Butte County taxpayers facing IRS or FTB collection: the 2018 Camp Fire still shapes the local tax docket
Butte County is the only California county whose tax-controversy profile was rewritten overnight by a single event. The November 2018 Camp Fire destroyed roughly 18,800 structures across Paradise, Magalia, Concow, and the surrounding foothill ridge, killed 85 people, and remains the deadliest and most destructive wildfire in California history. Years later, files still cross our desk that turn on the federal disaster-area rules: personal casualty losses under IRC §165(h) are deductible after 2017 only when attributable to a federally declared disaster, and Paradise sat inside the FEMA disaster declaration; statute-of-limitations postponement under IRC §7508A stretched filing and payment deadlines for affected taxpayers; insurance proceeds and PG&E Fire Victim Trust distributions trigger involuntary-conversion treatment under IRC §1033, with a replacement window that runs four years for principal residences in a federally declared disaster zone. Layered on top: CSU Chico stipends and fellowships under IRC §117, Sacramento Valley rice and orchard Schedule F audits, Enloe Medical Center physician 1099 and equity-comp matters, and the same FTB residency, CDTFA, and EDD exposure that touches every other California county. The Camp Fire is no longer current news, but it is current tax practice in Butte County.
$100M+
Total tax relief secured
2,000+
Tax cases resolved
5.0
Average rating · 72 reviews
CA-Based
LA HQ, serving all of Butte County
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Each tax case is unique and turns on individual facts and IRS or FTB discretion.
A California firm representing Butte County taxpayers across the Sacramento Valley floor and the Feather River foothills
Victory Tax Lawyers, LLP is a California-licensed tax-law firm with its principal office at 1100 S. Robertson Boulevard in Los Angeles. Both attorneys hold the State Bar of California license in active standing — Parham Khorsandi, Cal Bar #266658, and Amir Boroumand, Cal Bar #269570 — and both are admitted to practice before the United States Tax Court. Because we are California-admitted, we appear directly before the FTB, CDTFA, EDD, and the California Office of Tax Appeals on behalf of Butte County clients without a Form 2848 workaround or out-of-state co-counsel arrangement.
Butte County sits on the eastern edge of the Sacramento Valley, framed by the foothills of the Sierra Nevada and the Feather River canyon system. Five incorporated cities — Oroville (the county seat), Chico, Paradise, Gridley, and Biggs — anchor a county of roughly 200,000 residents. The unincorporated communities matter as much as the cities for tax-controversy purposes: Magalia and Concow on the ridge above Paradise, Berry Creek and Yankee Hill in the Feather River canyon, Forest Ranch and Cohasset above Chico, and Durham, Dayton, Nelson, Richvale, Palermo, Thermalito, Bangor, Honcut, and Stirling City scattered across the valley floor and the lower foothills. The Lake Oroville recreation economy in the northeastern corner of the county brings its own tax issues for boat-and-marina operators, vacation-rental owners, and seasonal tourism employers.
The tax-controversy profile is shaped by five economic anchors. First, the 2018 Camp Fire and its multi-year tax aftermath — PG&E Fire Victim Trust payouts began arriving in 2021 and continue, casualty-loss carryforwards from 2018 returns remain open on amended-return issues, IRC §1033 replacement windows for principal residences are still running for filers who took the four-year disaster-zone extension, and many displaced Paradise households are still working through the basis math on rebuilt or replacement homes. Second, California State University Chico is the largest employer of the city and the academic anchor of the county, generating §117 fellowship and stipend questions, graduate-student 1098-T versus 1099-NEC reporting issues, faculty consulting income, and out-of-state student residency questions that affect the §25A American Opportunity and Lifetime Learning Credits. Third, Enloe Medical Center is the regional hospital system serving Chico and the surrounding counties, with attendant physician W-2 plus 1099 locum stacking, RSU and profit-sharing exposure, and the underwithholding pattern common to all California hospital systems. Fourth, agriculture — rice on the Sacramento Valley floor (Richvale is the historical center of California rice and home to the Lundberg Family Farms operation), almonds, walnuts, kiwi, prunes, and stone fruit across the lower foothills, plus the cattle operations that come with the foothill grazing land — generates Schedule F audits, IRC §175 soil-and-water conservation issues, IRC §180 fertilizer-deduction issues, ag-employer EDD payroll exposure under the AB 1066 overtime rules, and the income-averaging election under IRC §1301. Fifth, Sierra Pacific Industries is the largest lumber producer in California and is headquartered in Anderson with substantial Butte County operations, anchoring a foothill timber-and-wood-products workforce with its own payroll, equipment depreciation, and worker-classification profile.
The rest of this page lays out the federal and California overlap as it applies to Butte County: the courthouses where these matters are heard, the Butte County Assessor and Treasurer-Tax Collector offices in Oroville that handle local property-tax exposure, the IRS Taxpayer Assistance Center serving the county from Chico, and the specific federal and state pressure points that hit Butte filers from the ag floor up to the foothill ridges.
Your tax rights as a Butte County taxpayer
Federal taxpayer rights are codified across the Internal Revenue Code and summarized in IRS Publication 1, the Taxpayer Bill of Rights. California layers its own taxpayer-rights regime on top, primarily through the FTB Taxpayer Bill of Rights at Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code Part 10.7 and parallel provisions for CDTFA and EDD. The major rights you can invoke in a Butte County tax matter:
Right to representation (federal)
Under IRC §7521(b)(2), an IRS examiner or collection officer must suspend an interview if you state you wish to consult an authorized representative. A signed Form 2848 puts your tax attorney between you and the IRS for the remainder of the matter. The IRS Chico Taxpayer Assistance Center on Ridgewood Drive — the TAC that serves Butte County — honors this at the in-person counter.
Right to representation (California)
FTB Form 3520-PIT (or 3520-BE for entities) appoints a representative with full authority before the Franchise Tax Board. CDTFA Form 392 and EDD DE 48 do the same for sales-tax and payroll matters. Once filed, all FTB Rancho Cordova headquarters notices route to counsel.
Right to Collection Due Process
After a Notice of Federal Tax Lien (IRC §6320) or a Final Notice of Intent to Levy (IRC §6330), you have 30 days to request a Collection Due Process hearing on Form 12153. CDP requests pause federal collection enforcement and preserve U.S. Tax Court review.
Right to OTA appeal
Effective 2018 under AB 102, the California Office of Tax Appeals hears appeals from FTB, CDTFA, and EDD determinations. The appeal window is 30 days from the Notice of Action for FTB matters. Butte County cases are heard at OTA Sacramento at 400 R Street, about 90 minutes south of Oroville on Highway 99.
Right to U.S. Tax Court review
A Notice of Deficiency triggers a 90-day petition window under IRC §6213(a). Butte County petitioners typically designate Sacramento as the place of trial — the Tax Court holds sessions at the Robert T. Matsui U.S. Courthouse at 501 I Street, Sacramento 95814. Calendared sessions run several times per year.
Right to a federal OIC
Under IRC §7122, the IRS may accept less than the full liability where doubt as to collectibility, doubt as to liability, or effective tax administration justifies settlement. Filed on Form 656 with Form 433-A(OIC) or 433-B(OIC).
Right to a California OIC
FTB has compromise authority under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §19443. CDTFA operates a parallel offer program under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §6832. EDD compromise authority sits at Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1192. Each program has its own form, financial-disclosure standard, and review track.
Right to a Collection Statute
IRC §6502 gives the IRS 10 years from assessment to collect. California's parallel period under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §19255 is 20 years — double the federal CSED. Pull both transcripts before negotiating.
How Victory Tax Lawyers helps Butte County taxpayers
Federal & California Offer in Compromise
We prepare and file federal Form 656 with Form 433-A(OIC) under IRC §7122, and FTB Form 4905 PIT or BE with the parallel California financial under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §19443. Camp Fire survivors who received PG&E Fire Victim Trust payouts often face the question of whether a portion is taxable under the §1033 framework, whether the §104 personal physical injury exclusion reaches any piece of the recovery, and how to model Reasonable Collection Potential when a rebuilt Paradise home has replaced a destroyed primary residence at a different basis. Chico-based Enloe physician and CSU Chico faculty files turn on the W-2 plus 1099 plus retirement-plan disposable-income math that recurs across California hospital and university systems.
Installment Agreements (IRS & FTB)
Streamlined IRS IAs under $50,000, Non-Streamlined IAs over $50,000 with Form 433-F disclosure, and Partial Pay Installment Agreements under IRC §6159 that run only through the CSED. FTB monthly-payment plans under FTB Form 3567. For Sacramento Valley rice and orchard operators with cyclical income, the disposable-income math has to account for off-season cash flow; for Enloe physicians and CSU Chico faculty, it turns on which housing and education-loan expenses survive the IRS Allowable Living Expense tables.
Lien release and withdrawal
A federal Notice of Federal Tax Lien under IRC §6321 and an FTB State Tax Lien under Cal. Gov. Code §7170 both attach to Butte County real and personal property and record at the Butte County Clerk-Recorder in Oroville. We pursue release after payment, certificate of discharge for refinancing or sale, subordination, and lien withdrawal under the Fresh Start program for IAs under $25,000. A lien on a Chico residential parcel or a Paradise rebuild can stall an escrow that has been months in the making.
Levy release (IRS, FTB, EDD)
Federal wage levies (CP90 / LT11) and bank levies under IRC §6331 stop with CNC, an accepted IA, an accepted OIC, or a CDP request. FTB Earnings Withholding Orders under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §18670 and bank levies under §18670.5 release under analogous resolutions. Enloe Medical Center, CSU Chico, Sierra Pacific Industries, and ag-employer payroll cycles in Butte County run on dates that require coordination on release timing to avoid a missed paycheck for the client.
Audit and exam defense
Federal correspondence, office, and field audits. FTB residency audits under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §17014. Schedule F farm audits across the Sacramento Valley rice belt and the foothill orchard country — almonds, walnuts, prunes, kiwi, and stone fruit operations all draw their share of IRS examination. CDTFA sales-tax audits on Chico restaurants, downtown retail, and equipment-and-supply businesses serving the ag industry. EDD AB 5 audits on farm labor contractors, packing-shed temp staffing, and Enloe medical-staffing arrangements.
Penalty abatement
Federal First-Time Penalty Abatement and reasonable-cause requests under IRC §6651. FTB penalty waivers under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §19131 (failure to file) and §19132 (failure to pay), and CDTFA waivers under §6592. Reasonable-cause grounds for Butte County filers include the 2018 Camp Fire and its multi-year displacement, the 2017 Oroville Dam spillway evacuation of roughly 188,000 downstream residents (which touched Oroville, Gridley, and Biggs directly), the 2020 North Complex / Bear Fire that burned across Berry Creek and Feather Falls and into the eastern county, the 2018 Carr Fire smoke that closed schools across the county, and the 2023 atmospheric-river flooding along the Feather River corridor.
12 types of Butte County tax issues we handle
Federal and California state practice areas, framed for the matters that walk in the door from Chico, Oroville, Paradise, Gridley, Biggs, and the unincorporated foothill and ag-floor communities.
Camp Fire personal casualty losses
Under IRC §165(h) as amended by the TCJA, personal casualty losses are deductible after 2017 only when attributable to a federally declared disaster. Paradise sat inside the 2018 federal disaster declaration, which preserved the deduction for Camp Fire losses. The math turns on adjusted basis, fair market value before and after, insurance reimbursement, and the $100 floor plus 10-percent-of-AGI threshold. Many 2018 returns took the federal disaster-area election under §165(i) to claim the loss against 2017 income, accelerating the refund cycle. Amended-return and carryforward questions still surface years later.
PG&E Fire Victim Trust distributions
Distributions from the PG&E Fire Victim Trust began arriving in 2021 and continued in multiple pro-rata installments. The tax treatment turns on the underlying claim category: physical-injury and physical-sickness recoveries under IRC §104(a)(2) are excludable; property-loss recoveries are recovery-of-basis and excess-over-basis (gain) under §1033 with the four-year replacement window for principal residences in a federally declared disaster; emotional-distress recoveries are taxable unless attributable to physical injury; and punitive components are taxable. The Trust does not issue tax allocation per claimant — the allocation is the taxpayer's burden.
IRC §1033 involuntary conversion
A Paradise homeowner whose principal residence was destroyed and who received insurance and Trust proceeds in excess of basis can defer gain recognition under IRC §1033 by reinvesting in replacement property of like kind within the statutory window — four years for a principal residence in a federally declared disaster area, two years for other property. The Section 121 $250,000 / $500,000 exclusion may also apply where the destroyed property was a principal residence. The interaction between §121, §1033, and the §165(i) prior-year election is fact-intensive and produces refund opportunities years after the original event.
CSU Chico §117 stipend and fellowship
Under IRC §117, qualified scholarships and fellowships used for tuition and required fees are excludable from gross income; stipends for room, board, or other living expenses are not, and amounts paid for required teaching or research services are taxable as compensation. CSU Chico graduate students and post-docs often receive a mixed package that has been reported on a 1098-T, a 1099-NEC, or a W-2 inconsistently across years. Out-of-state students claiming California residency for §25A credits add a residency layer. The audit risk concentrates on the line between the §117 exclusion and Form 8606 / Form 1040 ordinary income.
Sacramento Valley rice Schedule F
Richvale and the surrounding Sacramento Valley rice belt produces a significant share of California rice. Schedule F audits in this corridor turn on crop-insurance proceeds under IRC §451(f) deferral elections, the §1301 farm income averaging election, prepaid farm expenses under §464, depreciation on irrigation equipment under §179 and bonus depreciation under §168(k), and the §180 fertilizer-and-soil-conditioner deduction. Co-op patronage dividends from operations like Lundberg Family Farms have their own §199A(g) deduction profile after the TCJA changes.
Orchard depreciation and basis
Almond, walnut, prune, kiwi, and stone-fruit operations across the lower foothills and the valley floor put pre-productive costs into orchard basis under IRC §263A, then depreciate under §168 once the orchard reaches commercial production. Tree-replacement and replanting after frost, fire, or disease is a separate basis question. The §179 expensing limit interacts with orchard-equipment purchases, and the §199A pass-through deduction reaches qualified ag operations through the patronage-dividend mechanism.
Enloe physician 1099 stacking
Enloe Medical Center staff physicians frequently take outside locum-tenens 1099 work at rural urgent-care chains, Plumas District Hospital coverage, Glenn Medical Center, and Oroville Hospital. The W-2 withholds at the marginal-rate-minus-allowances level while the 1099 has zero withholding; April balances routinely arrive in the high five figures or low six figures. Quarterly estimates under IRC §6654 are the fix — not the discovery in April.
Trust Fund Recovery Penalty
Under IRC §6672, the IRS pierces the corporate veil for unpaid payroll trust funds. Chico downtown restaurants and retail, Oroville contractors and auto-service shops, Gridley and Biggs ag-services and ag-supply firms, and Paradise rebuild-area construction subs that fell behind on Form 941 deposits often discover this through Form 4180 interviews. EDD parallel exposure runs under Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1735.
EDD AB 5 ag and contractor classification
Farm labor contractors, packing-shed seasonal staffing, orchard pruning and harvest crews, and Paradise-rebuild construction subs reclassified from 1099 to W-2 under the Dynamex ABC test now codified at Cal. Lab. Code §2775. Back UI, ETT, SDI, and PIT withholding for three years plus penalties. AB 1066 ag-overtime layers on top, and the H-2A program brings its own federal payroll-and-tax compliance issues for foreign agricultural workers.
Lake Oroville tourism CDTFA audits
Lake Oroville is the second-largest reservoir in California and anchors a recreation economy of marina-and-boat-rental operators, jet-ski concessions, lakeside cabin rentals, RV parks, and seasonal food-and-beverage retail. CDTFA mark-up audits in the corridor use observation tests and POS reconciliation. The seasonal swing — busy Memorial-to-Labor-Day, slow rest of the year — makes a 12-month look-back versus shoulder-season pull a fact-intensive fight.
Sierra Pacific lumber payroll
Sierra Pacific Industries is the largest lumber producer in California, with substantial Butte County milling and logging operations. The lumber-and-wood-products workforce produces standard W-2 employment-tax matters plus contractor classification questions on logging subs and independent timber-falling crews, equipment-depreciation issues for the operators, and reforestation expensing under IRC §194 for the company's land holdings. Worker injury, §127 educational-assistance plans, and pension issues all show up.
Innocent Spouse Relief
Federal Form 8857 relief under IRC §6015 and California parallel relief under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §18533. California is a community-property state under Cal. Fam. Code §760. The analysis is fact-heavy, especially in Camp-Fire-affected households where insurance and Trust proceeds were received during a marriage that ended during the displacement period, and in Enloe-physician-and-spouse files where the physician's outside 1099 income drives a balance the non-physician spouse never saw on paper.
Nine common causes of tax debt in Butte County
1. Camp Fire recovery missteps
A Paradise homeowner received insurance plus PG&E Trust proceeds exceeding adjusted basis. The owner did not file the §1033 election to defer gain, did not track replacement-property costs against the four-year window, and did not properly allocate the Trust payment between §104 excludable physical-injury portions and taxable economic-loss portions. The result: an IRS assessment on the gain years after the fire, with the four-year replacement window already expired.
2. Ag income volatility
A Sacramento Valley rice operation has a strong year, a weak year, then a strong year. The operator did not make the IRC §1301 income-averaging election to smooth the marginal rate across the three years, did not defer crop-insurance proceeds under §451(f), and did not pre-pay deductible expenses under §464 in the strong year. The result: a top-bracket assessment in the peak year that could have been spread or deferred with planning.
3. Enloe physician outside locum income
An Enloe Medical Center staff physician takes urgent-care locum shifts on the side or covers a rural-hospital ER under a 1099 arrangement. The 1099 income arrives without withholding, the marginal rate sits at 35 to 37 percent federal plus 11.3 to 13.3 percent California, and the April balance lands in the five or six figures. Form 2210 underpayment penalties under IRC §6654 stack on top.
4. CSU Chico stipend mis-reporting
A graduate student receives a mixed package — tuition waiver plus stipend plus required teaching duties. The university reports the package on a 1098-T or 1099-NEC. The student excludes the entire amount under §117. The IRS issues a CP2000 reclassifying the teaching-services portion as compensation. Multiple years compound before the student notices.
5. Farm equipment depreciation errors
A Butte County orchard operator buys a $400,000 self-propelled harvester. The operator elects §179 expensing without coordinating with the §179 taxable-income limitation, or claims bonus depreciation on used equipment without confirming the §168(k) used-property eligibility introduced by the TCJA and modified since. The deduction is disallowed on examination and shifted to a multi-year depreciation schedule.
6. ERC clawback exposure
Employee Retention Credit claims submitted by promoter mills are being clawed back through CP207/CP207L letters. Chico restaurants and retail, Oroville construction firms, Paradise rebuild contractors, ag operations that mis-claimed under the partial-suspension test, and Lake Oroville tourism operators are all inside the audit wave.
7. Small-business payroll lapses
A Chico downtown retailer, Oroville auto shop, Paradise-rebuild construction sub, Gridley ag-supply operator, or Lake Oroville marina stops depositing 941 trust funds during a slow quarter or off-season. The IRS asserts TFRP against the owner personally under IRC §6672, and EDD assesses parallel state payroll under Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1735.
8. Unreported gambling and casino income
The Gold Country Casino & Hotel in Oroville (Tyme Maidu Tribe) and Feather Falls Casino & Lodge near Oroville produce W-2G wage-reporting that filers occasionally miss. The IRS matches the W-2G to filed returns and issues CP2000 assessments. Slot and table winnings interact with the §165(d) gambling-loss deduction, which is now capped at gambling winnings and requires substantiation.
9. Disaster-disrupted filing
Filers affected by the 2018 Camp Fire, the 2017 Oroville Dam spillway crisis evacuation, the 2020 North Complex / Bear Fire that burned through Berry Creek, the 2018 Carr Fire and 2018 Mendocino Complex smoke that closed schools across Chico and Oroville, and the 2023 atmospheric-river flooding along the Feather River corridor missed deadlines. Disaster-zone extensions help, but penalty stacks accumulate fast when the disaster window lapses.
Who is on the hook: eight Butte County tax-liability scenarios
Joint filers (community-property state)
California is a community-property state under Cal. Fam. Code §760. Joint federal returns create joint-and-several liability under IRC §6013(d)(3). One spouse can be pursued for the entire balance — even after divorce — subject to Innocent Spouse Relief under IRC §6015 and Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §18533. Especially relevant in Camp-Fire-affected households where insurance and Trust proceeds were received during a marriage that ended during the displacement period.
Partnership general partners
Under IRC §6231 and the BBA centralized partnership audit regime, general partners of Butte County ag partnerships, orchard-operating LLCs taxed as partnerships, rice mill ventures, real-estate-rebuild partnerships in Paradise and Magalia, and Chico professional-practice partnerships face imputed underpayment liability for partnership-level adjustments. Push-out elections under IRC §6226 shift the burden to the partners' year of audit.
Responsible persons for payroll
Trust Fund Recovery Penalty under IRC §6672 reaches anyone with check-signing authority who willfully failed to pay over withheld taxes. State parallel sits at Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1735 for EDD payroll. Reaches Chico, Oroville, Paradise, and ag-floor small-business owners after the entity folds — particularly common in the seasonal ag and tourism sectors and among Paradise rebuild contractors who took on more crew than the cash flow supported.
CDTFA dual-determinations
CDTFA issues dual-determination notices personally against corporate officers, directors, and LLC members of entities that fail to remit sales tax in trust, under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §6829. Common against Chico restaurant operators, Oroville retail, Paradise rebuild-area material suppliers, and Lake Oroville tourism entities after the business closes.
FTB suspended-entity personal exposure
An entity that fails to pay California minimum franchise tax or file a Statement of Information is suspended by FTB under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §23301. While suspended, the entity loses its right to contract, sue, or defend in California courts — including the Butte County Superior Court at the Butte County Courthouse in Oroville and the North Butte County Courthouse in Chico. Officers signing on behalf during suspension can incur personal exposure.
Transferee liability
IRC §6901 reaches a transferee of assets where the transfer rendered the transferor insolvent and tax debts remain unpaid. Butte County family-LLC restructurings, multi-generation orchard and rice-farm successions, Prop 19 parent-to-child transfers under Cal. Const. Art. XIII A on Chico, Durham, and Paradise rebuild homes, intra-family trust funding moves, and Camp-Fire-rebuild gift transfers can all trigger this analysis.
Successor business liability
Asset purchases of a Butte County restaurant, orchard operation, ag-supply business, Paradise-area rebuild contractor, or Lake Oroville lodging operation can carry forward CDTFA sales-tax successor liability under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §6811-6814 and EDD payroll successor liability under Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1731. Clearance letters from CDTFA and EDD before close are the buyer's protection — particularly important on rebuild-area construction asset purchases where cash-flow gaps have hidden 941 lapses.
Estate and decedent returns
California has no state estate tax; the decedent's final 1040 and the estate's 1041 are the executor's responsibility. Personal liability for the executor attaches under 31 USC §3713(b) if distributions are made before federal tax claims are satisfied. Probate of Butte County estates — including multi-generation orchard and rice-farm holdings — moves through the Butte County Superior Court Probate Division.
What resolution can look like in Butte County
Debt reduced
An accepted federal OIC settles the IRS liability for less than the full amount. A parallel FTB §19443 compromise can settle the California side — the same compromise unit handles Butte County files out of FTB headquarters in Rancho Cordova, 90 minutes south of Oroville. Partial Pay IAs cap recovery at what you can pay through the federal CSED or the FTB 20-year statute. Currently Not Collectible status freezes federal collection while finances stabilize after a Camp Fire displacement, an ag-income downturn, or a medical or family event.
Penalties abated
Federal First-Time Penalty Abatement removes failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties for a clean compliance year. Reasonable-cause requests address the 2018 Camp Fire displacement, the 2017 Oroville Dam spillway evacuation, the 2020 North Complex / Bear Fire, the 2023 atmospheric-river flooding, serious illness, and preparer reliance. FTB waivers under §19131 and §19132 follow parallel principles.
Liens and levies released
A federal NFTL withdraws once a streamlined IA is in place under Fresh Start. FTB State Tax Liens release on payment, accepted compromise, or release-for-cause — critical when refinancing or selling Butte County real property, including Paradise rebuild parcels still recovering market value after 2018. Wage and bank levies stop when the account moves to CNC, IA, or OIC processing. Passport certifications reverse once federal debt drops below the §7345 threshold.
Outcomes vary. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Each tax case is unique.
Settlement ranges from the firm's case files
The following ranges come from Victory Tax Lawyers cases over the past several years and contribute to the firm's $100M+ aggregate tax-relief figure. Names and identifying facts are removed for confidentiality.
| Matter type | Original liability | Resolution | Approximate result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Installment Agreement | $138,296 | IRC §6159 streamlined IA | $25/month accepted |
| Partial Pay IA | $126,489 | IRC §6159 PPIA through CSED | $50/month accepted |
| Installment Agreement | $128,206 | IRC §6159 streamlined IA | $25/month accepted |
| Partial Pay IA | $116,451 | IRC §6159 PPIA through CSED | $50/month accepted |
| Installment Agreement | $152,296 | IRC §6159 streamlined IA | $25/month accepted |
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Each tax case is unique and turns on facts, asset position, monthly disposable income, IRS Allowable Living Expense tables, FTB equivalent standards, and the discretion of the assigned Revenue Officer, Settlement Officer, or FTB compromise reviewer. Acceptance rates for federal Offer in Compromise vary widely — the IRS reported a nationwide acceptance rate of roughly 30 to 40 percent in recent years.
Why work with a California-licensed firm on a Butte County tax matter
Butte County taxpayers deal with two tax systems that interact in ways most out-of-state firms do not understand — and a third layer of complication arrives from the Camp Fire aftermath that continues to shape returns and audits years after the event. A Paradise rebuild family with a destroyed primary residence under §1033, a PG&E Trust distribution that ran across §104 excludable and taxable components, and a federal §165(i) prior-year election can have an IRS examination on one front, an FTB residency or basis question on another, and a Butte County Assessor Prop 13 base-year-value transfer issue on a third. A federal NFTL filed with the Butte County Clerk-Recorder in Oroville sits in the same recording index as the FTB's own State Tax Lien against the same Chico or Paradise rebuild parcel. The matters do not stay in their lanes.
Victory Tax Lawyers is California-admitted, headquartered in Los Angeles, and built around exactly this overlap. Parham Khorsandi (Cal Bar #266658) and Amir Boroumand (Cal Bar #269570) appear directly before the FTB, CDTFA, EDD, and the California Office of Tax Appeals, and on the federal side before the IRS and the U.S. Tax Court. No out-of-state coordination, no Form 2848 workaround. The same attorneys handle the whole engagement from initial Form 12153 through final Tax Court trial in Sacramento.
California is one of the more lawyer-intensive tax environments in the country. The State Bar's Rule of Professional Conduct 7.1 (formerly Rule 1-400) tightly governs lawyer advertising in the state — no superlatives without verifiable substantiation, no specific dollar guarantees, no testimonials without disclaimers. The firm operates under those rules natively, which is why this page does not promise outcomes, does not promote dollar averages without context, and does not list testimonials without proper disclosure.
Butte County is also distinctive for the practice mix the geography and recent history produce. The Camp Fire files, Sacramento Valley ag matters, CSU Chico stipend issues, and Enloe physician 1099 cases that show up here are not the same matters that walk in the door in San Diego or Los Angeles. That practice density shapes how we approach a Butte County engagement.
The seven steps of a VTL tax-resolution engagement
Free consultation
A 30-minute call with an attorney to outline the facts, the IRS or FTB notices received, and the realistic resolution options for a Butte County matter.
Engagement letter
A written attorney-client agreement defines scope, fee, and authority. California-bar privilege and federal common-law attorney-client privilege both attach.
Federal & state PoA
Form 2848 filed with the IRS, FTB Form 3520, CDTFA Form 392, or EDD DE 48 filed with the relevant California agency. All notices route to counsel.
Transcript investigation
IRS Account Transcripts, Wage-and-Income Transcripts, and Record of Account pulled across all open years. FTB MyFTB account, CDTFA records, and EDD records pulled. Federal CSED and California 20-year statute dates verified.
Strategy memo
A written analysis recommending federal OIC, IA, CNC, audit response, CDP, or Tax Court petition — with the FTB, CDTFA, or EDD parallel strategy where applicable.
Resolution filed
Federal Forms 656, 433-A, 9423, 12153, or Tax Court Petition. State FTB Form 4905, CDTFA offer, or EDD compromise. Negotiations with Revenue Officers, Settlement Officers, Appeals Officers, FTB analysts, CDTFA supervisors, and OTA hearings handled directly.
Compliance close-out
Post-resolution monitoring: quarterly estimates, return filings, and protection against IA default on either side. The case is done when the new pattern is stable, not when the offer is accepted.
Collection statute warning — the California 20-year tail
Under IRC §6502(a), the IRS generally has ten years from the date of assessment to collect a tax. After the federal Collection Statute Expiration Date, the debt becomes uncollectible by operation of law. Tolling events that extend the federal CSED include a pending Offer in Compromise (extends by OIC pendency plus 30 days), bankruptcy filing (extends by bankruptcy stay plus six months), Collection Due Process hearings (extends while pending), Innocent Spouse claims, and continuous absence from the United States for six months or more. IRC §7508A postponements for federally declared disasters — including the 2018 Camp Fire declaration — also toll the CSED for affected taxpayers during the postponement window.
The California side is the opposite of forgiving. Under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §19255, the FTB has 20 years from the latest of the assessment, the date the liability becomes due and payable, or the date a final return was filed, to collect. That is double the federal CSED. CDTFA collection statutes for sales-and-use tax are governed by Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §6711, generally 10 years from determination but with similar tolling. EDD has its own collection window under Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code §1701.
The practical impact for a Butte County filer: a federal balance assessed in 2016 may be approaching CSED expiration in 2026, while the FTB equivalent continues to be collectible until 2036. Submitting a federal OIC restarts the federal clock. Sometimes a Partial Pay IA that runs out the federal statute is the better federal play, paired with a separate FTB compromise to address the longer state tail. For Camp Fire survivors who relocated outside California after 2018, the FTB tail still attaches to California-source income earned during years of California residency — the move forward does not erase the look-back.
Butte County venue: where federal and state tax matters are heard
Butte County's tax-controversy venues split between the Sacramento federal corridor 90 minutes south and the county's own state courts in Oroville and Chico. The U.S. Tax Court designates Sacramento as the place of trial for Butte County petitioners. The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California also sits in Sacramento. The Butte County Superior Court's main venue is the Butte County Courthouse in Oroville at One Court Street, with the North Butte County Courthouse in Chico at 1775 Concord Avenue handling matters originating in the Chico area. State matters at the FTB, CDTFA, and EDD that reach a formal appeal proceed through the California Office of Tax Appeals at its Sacramento hearing location at 400 R Street.
U.S. Tax Court — Sacramento trial sessions
The U.S. Tax Court designates Sacramento as a place of trial under Tax Court Rule 140. Sessions are held at the Robert T. Matsui U.S. Courthouse at 501 I Street, Sacramento 95814 — roughly 90 minutes south of Oroville on Highway 99. Butte County petitioners typically designate Sacramento on the deficiency petition; sessions are calendared several times per year.
IRS Taxpayer Assistance Center — Chico
The IRS Chico Taxpayer Assistance Center at 1395 Ridgewood Drive, Chico 95973 is the TAC that serves Butte County and the surrounding northern Sacramento Valley counties. Appointments are required and arranged through apps.irs.gov/app/office-locator or 844-545-5640. The TAC handles in-person account inquiries, payment intake, identity verification, and ITIN applications.
Butte County Treasurer-Tax Collector
The Butte County Treasurer-Tax Collector at 25 County Center Drive, Oroville 95965 administers Butte County property-tax billing, collection, defaulted-property auctions, and unsecured-roll collections through its Treasury, Property Tax, and Central Collections divisions. Property-tax delinquencies on Butte County real property — including those triggered by Prop 13 reassessment changes on Paradise rebuild parcels — route through this office.
Butte County Assessor
The Butte County Assessor at 25 County Center Drive, Suite 100, Oroville 95965 sets Prop 13 base-year value and annual assessed value for every parcel in the county. Prop 19 parent-to-child reassessment exclusions, Prop 8 decline-in-value applications relevant to Paradise and Magalia rebuild parcels still recovering market value after the Camp Fire, and assessment appeals to the Butte County Assessment Appeals Board start here.
Butte County Superior Court
The Butte County Superior Court operates two courthouses. The main Butte County Courthouse sits at One Court Street, Oroville 95965, and the North Butte County Courthouse sits at 1775 Concord Avenue, Chico 95928. The court handles state-tax civil actions, FTB and CDTFA collection litigation, judicial review of OTA decisions, probate proceedings with tax components (including multi-generation orchard and rice-farm estates), and divorce matters involving community-property tax allocation.
FTB headquarters — Rancho Cordova
The California Franchise Tax Board headquarters at 9646 Butterfield Way, Rancho Cordova 95827 administers FTB collection and audit infrastructure for the state. Personal-income-tax audits, residency examinations under Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §17014, corporate franchise-tax matters, and the §19443 compromise unit all sit on this campus — roughly 90 minutes south of Oroville.
U.S. District Court — Eastern District of California
Butte County sits in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California. Federal refund suits and criminal-tax cases involving Butte County defendants proceed at the Robert T. Matsui U.S. Courthouse at 501 I Street, Sacramento 95814 — the same building that houses Tax Court sessions. Appellate review goes to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco.
California Office of Tax Appeals
The California Office of Tax Appeals was created in 2018 under AB 102 to hear appeals from FTB, CDTFA, and EDD determinations. Butte County matters are heard at OTA Sacramento at 400 R Street. Three-judge panels of Administrative Law Judges; decisions are precedential and published.
VTL represents clients in all five incorporated cities of Butte County — Oroville, Chico, Paradise, Gridley, and Biggs — and across the unincorporated communities including Magalia, Concow, Berry Creek, Yankee Hill, Forest Ranch, Cohasset, Durham, Dayton, Nelson, Richvale, Palermo, Thermalito, Bangor, Honcut, and Stirling City.
Request a free consultation with a Butte County tax attorney
A 30-minute call with an attorney costs nothing. Bring your most recent IRS notice, your last filed federal and California returns, any Camp Fire insurance settlement statements or PG&E Fire Victim Trust correspondence if you are a Paradise-area filer, any Schedule F worksheets if you operate a Sacramento Valley rice or orchard business, any 1099 locum or RSU statements if you are an Enloe physician or CSU Chico faculty member, and any FTB, CDTFA, EDD, or Butte County Treasurer-Tax Collector correspondence. We will tell you which resolution options actually fit your facts — on both the federal and California sides — before you sign anything.
Office: 1100 S. Robertson Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA 90035. Serving all 5 incorporated cities of Butte County plus the foothill and ag-floor unincorporated communities by phone, secure portal, and in-person by appointment.
Frequently asked questions for Butte County taxpayers
Reviewed by
Parham Khorsandi, Esq.
Managing Attorney · California Bar #266658 · Admitted to the United States Tax Court
Parham Khorsandi is the managing attorney of Victory Tax Lawyers, LLP, headquartered at 1100 S. Robertson Boulevard in Los Angeles. His practice focuses on federal and California tax controversy, including Offer in Compromise negotiations before the IRS and FTB, Installment Agreements, Trust Fund Recovery Penalty defense, disaster-area casualty-loss and IRC §1033 involuntary-conversion work in the wake of the 2018 Camp Fire, FTB residency audits, Schedule F farm audits across the Sacramento Valley rice belt and the foothill orchard country, CSU Chico §117 stipend matters, Enloe physician 1099 and RSU work, CDTFA sales-tax representation, EDD worker-classification audits, OTA appeals, and litigation before the U.S. Tax Court Sacramento sessions. He has represented Butte County individuals and businesses across Chico, Oroville, Paradise, Gridley, Biggs, and the foothill and ag-floor unincorporated communities.
Last Reviewed:
Attorney Advertising. Victory Tax Lawyers, LLP is a California-licensed law firm with its principal office at 1100 S. Robertson Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA 90035. Information on this page is general in nature, may not reflect the most recent legal developments, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. This page is not legal advice. Federal and California tax outcomes depend on individual facts and the discretion of the Internal Revenue Service, the Franchise Tax Board, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the Employment Development Department, the Butte County Treasurer-Tax Collector, the Butte County Assessor, or the relevant tribunal. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes; each tax matter is unique.
IRS Circular 230 Disclosure. To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, any U.S. federal tax advice contained on this page is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing, or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.
California-specific note. VTL attorneys are members of the State Bar of California in active standing. California state-tax matters (FTB, CDTFA, EDD, OTA), Butte County property-tax matters, and federal IRS / U.S. Tax Court matters are handled directly by the firm. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation before acting on any content on this page. The State Bar of California Rule of Professional Conduct 7.1 requires that lawyer communications not be false or misleading; this page strives to comply with that rule and does not promise specific outcomes.
Related VTL practice areas
Offer in Compromise
IRC §7122 settlement
Installment Agreement
IRC §6159 payment plan
Tax Lien
IRC §6321 release
Tax Levy
IRC §6331 release
Audit Representation
IRS exam defense
Penalty Abatement
First-Time and reasonable cause
Back Taxes
Unfiled returns and balances
California Tax Attorney
State hub
All areas we serve
Nationwide coverage