Fresh Start vs. Offer in Compromise: What's the Difference?
Fresh Start is the policy package. The Offer in Compromise is one of the tools inside it. Here's how the two connect, and how to tell which one fits your balance.
Short version: you can't apply for "Fresh Start" by name. Fresh Start is the label the IRS gave to a set of collection policy changes it announced in 2011 and 2012, covering tax liens, installment agreements and Offers in Compromise. The Offer in Compromise (OIC) is one of the tools those changes touched, and it's the only one that can lower the amount you owe. So the comparison most people actually need is narrower: pay the full debt over time under an installment agreement, or ask the IRS to accept less through an offer. If you want the general overview first, start with our guide to IRS Fresh Start Program eligibility and application.
What Fresh Start changed for Offers in Compromise
The OIC program is decades older than Fresh Start. What Fresh Start did was change the math the IRS uses to decide whether an offer is acceptable.
On May 21, 2012, the IRS announced the OIC phase of Fresh Start in news release IR-2012-53. The biggest change was to future income. When the IRS works out your reasonable collection potential, it adds the equity in your assets to a multiple of the money you have left each month after allowable expenses. Before 2012 that multiple covered four years of income for short offers and five years for longer ones. Now it works like this:
- Lump-sum offers, paid in 5 or fewer payments within 5 months of acceptance: 12 months of future income, down from 48.
- Periodic-payment offers, paid monthly over 6 to 24 months: 24 months of future income, down from 60.
Here's what that does to a real number. Say a household has $500 a month left over. Under the old lump-sum rule, the future-income part of the offer was $24,000 ($500 x 48). Under the current rule it's $6,000 ($500 x 12). Asset equity gets added on top either way, but the drop in that one line is often what makes an offer worth filing.
The same release opened up expenses the IRS had been reluctant to allow:
- payments on federally guaranteed loans for post-high-school education
- payments on delinquent state and local taxes, allowed on a percentage basis tied to what you owe the state compared with the IRS
- a wider National Standard miscellaneous allowance, which can cover things like credit card payments and bank fees
It also narrowed when the IRS counts "dissipated" assets (money spent or moved before you applied) and said equity in income-producing assets generally won't count against an ongoing business.
Those rules are still in force. The worksheet in the April 2026 revision of the IRS Form 656-B booklet multiplies remaining monthly income by 12 for offers paid in 5 months or less and by 24 for offers paid over 6 to 24 months. Work through those lines on Form 433-A (OIC) before you settle on an offer amount.
Installment agreement vs. Offer in Compromise, side by side
Most people comparing these two already know they can't pay the whole bill this month. The real difference is what happens to the balance. A payment plan spreads it out. An accepted offer shrinks it.
| Installment agreement | Offer in Compromise | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | People who can pay the full balance before the collection statute runs out. Simple payment plans cover balances of $50,000 or less with no financial statement. | People whose income and asset equity, measured by the IRS formula, fall short of the full balance. No dollar cap. |
| Forms | IRS Online Payment Agreement tool, or Form 9465 by mail | Form 656 plus Form 433-A (OIC) for individuals or Form 433-B (OIC) for businesses |
| Upfront cost | $0 for a short-term plan (180 days or less). Long-term plans: $29 online with direct debit, up to $178 by phone, mail or in person without direct debit. | $205 application fee, plus an initial payment: 20% of the offer for lump-sum offers, or the first monthly payment for periodic offers |
| Low-income relief | Setup fee waived with direct debit; $43 otherwise, which may be reimbursed | Low-income certification waives the fee and all payments during review. For a one-person household in the 48 contiguous states, the 2026 limit is $39,900. |
| Timeline | The IRS says online applicants get an approval decision as soon as they finish the application. | A detailed financial review that often runs for months. By law, an offer is treated as accepted if the IRS makes no decision within two years of receiving it. |
| Debt reduced? | No. Interest and some penalties keep accruing until the balance is paid. | Yes, if accepted. The IRS agrees to settle for less than the full amount owed. |
| Federal tax liens | A lien can still be filed. With a direct debit plan of $25,000 or less that pays in full within 60 months, you can request withdrawal after 3 consecutive payments. | The IRS may file a lien during review. After acceptance, it's generally released within 45 days of your final payment being received and verified. |
| Compliance | All required returns filed, and you stay current on new taxes while the plan runs. | All returns filed and current estimated payments made before you apply, then 5 years of on-time filing and payment after acceptance, or the offer can default. |
Fees and limits come from the IRS payment plans page, the Offer in Compromise page and the Form 656-B booklet. The IRS adjusts them, so check those pages before you file.
Which one fits your situation
Start with one question. Could you pay the full balance before the IRS's collection window closes? The IRS generally has 10 years from assessment to collect (see our guide to the collection statute expiration date). If the answer is yes, an offer is a long shot. The Form 656-B booklet says the IRS generally won't accept one if you can pay in full through an installment agreement, your asset equity, or both.
A few patterns we see often:
- You owe $50,000 or less and have steady pay. A simple payment plan is usually the quicker route. You can set it up online without a financial statement.
- Your balance is large, your income dropped, and you don't have much equity. Run the IRS OIC Pre-Qualifier tool, then the 433-A (OIC) numbers. If your collection potential lands well below what you owe, an offer deserves a serious look.
- You can pay something monthly, just not enough to finish before the statute expires. A partial pay installment agreement may fit better than an offer. Our page on Offer in Compromise vs. installment agreement walks through it.
- You can't pay anything right now. Currently Not Collectible status pauses collection while interest keeps running. See our IRS hardship program guide.
One hard stop: if you're in an open bankruptcy, you can't file an offer at all. Any deal has to happen inside the bankruptcy case.
Can you combine them?
Not for the same debt at the same moment. They do work in sequence, though, and the order matters.
If you already have an approved installment agreement and then submit an offer, Form 656-B says you don't have to keep making plan payments while the IRS considers it. If the offer isn't accepted and you haven't run up new tax debt, the IRS reinstates your plan. A plan that's still pending (accepted for processing but not yet approved) is a different story: it gets withdrawn and won't come back on its own.
A periodic-payment offer is, in effect, both at once. You pay a reduced amount in monthly installments over 6 to 24 months.
If the IRS rejects your offer, you have the right to appeal, and a payment plan is still on the table. After an offer is accepted, though, the door narrows. For the five-year compliance period you can't request an installment agreement for unpaid taxes from before or after the accepted offer, and you can't file a new offer. Miss a filing or a payment in that window and the IRS can default the deal, which puts the original balance back, minus what you paid, plus interest and penalties.
When you're ready to file, here's how to apply for an Offer in Compromise. If you'd rather have a lawyer check the numbers first, talk with our Offer in Compromise attorney team. We'll review your 433-A (OIC) figures with you and explain whether an offer, a payment plan or another option matches your finances.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an Offer in Compromise part of the Fresh Start program?
Partly. The Offer in Compromise existed long before 2011. Fresh Start is the name the IRS gave to a group of collection policy changes in 2011 and 2012, and one of those changes, announced in IR-2012-53, rewrote how the IRS calculates an acceptable offer. So an OIC filed today is shaped by Fresh Start rules, but you apply for it on Form 656, not through a separate Fresh Start application.
Did Fresh Start make it easier to get an Offer in Compromise accepted?
It changed the math in your favor. The IRS now counts 12 months of future income for lump-sum offers and 24 months for periodic-payment offers, down from four and five years before 2012, and it allows certain expenses such as federally guaranteed student loan payments. Acceptance still depends on your reasonable collection potential, so a lower formula does not mean every offer gets approved.
Does the IRS stop collection while my offer is under review?
Mostly. The IRS suspends other collection activity while your offer is pending, but it can still levy up to the point an IRS official signs and acknowledges the offer as pending, and it may file a Notice of Federal Tax Lien during the review. Interest and penalties keep accruing, and the collection statute is extended while the offer is open.
What happens to my tax refund if I submit an offer?
The IRS can keep any refund, including interest, for a return assessed before the date it accepts your offer, and apply it to your tax debt. That refund does not count as a payment toward your offer amount. You also cannot use an expected refund to fund the offer.
Is the $205 Offer in Compromise application fee refundable?
Generally no. The IRS treats the fee as nonrefundable. Two exceptions are worth knowing: if you qualify for low-income certification you do not pay the fee at all, and if the IRS returns your offer because you have unfiled returns, it sends back the offer and the application fee but applies any initial payment to your tax debt.
This content was written and reviewed by the licensed tax attorneys at Victory Tax Lawyers, LLP. Our attorneys specialize in IRS tax relief and are licensed members of the California State Bar with a nationwide practice.
Last Reviewed: 2026 · Meet Our Attorneys →
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by viewing or using this website. For legal advice, please schedule a consultation.
© Victory Tax Lawyers © 2026. All rights reserved. Powered by GLP Marketing
Ready to Resolve Your Tax Issues?
Our experienced tax attorneys have saved clients over $91 million. Get a free, confidential consultation today.